Hiring for a Major Remodel? Here are 12 Contractor Qualities that Matter Most
- 6 days ago
- 4 min read
Kitsap County, home to approximately 275,000 residents, offers the rare combination of regional scale and a close-knit community feel. Kitsap County’s deep military roots and strong sense of community, combined with Bainbridge Island’s thoughtful, design-aware homeowners, naturally demand the highest level of craftsmanship. Homeowners are happy to share their home construction journeys and point out the companies that helped them build a legacy for their next generations.
Homeowners who live here benefit from hiring local contractors. They enjoy quicker response times, a deep understanding of local materials and weather patterns, and the assurance of working with professionals whose reputations are closely tied to the community.
Hiring an established local construction team and reviewing the checklist below will help avoid painful mistakes. Here are 12 contractor qualities that matter most when choosing the right company for your custom build or home remodel.
1. License, bonding, and insurance coverage
2. Local presence/office
3. Recognition/awards given by the industry/community
4. Local references and client testimonials
5. Knowledge of county and city building codes and understanding of zoning rules, permits, and inspections
6. Awareness of local materials, suppliers, and subcontractor networks
7. Experience with site-specific challenges: soil, topography, weather patterns,
8. Familiarity with Bainbridge Island-specific logistics, like ferry schedules, material transport limitations, or seasonal weather constraints
9. Participation in local builder associations or chambers of commerce
10. Willingness to answer questions and explain options clearly
11. Provides a clear contract and scope of work
12. No past legal or regulatory issues
5 Red Flags That Should Make You Walk Away
1. Prices That Seem “Too Good to Be True”
When a construction company’s bid deviates dramatically from all others, it warrants careful scrutiny and heightened caution. Unrealistic bids signal incomplete scope, hidden fees, or shortcuts. Probe deeply to understand the assumptions, exclusions, and methods driving the discrepancy. When a bid is unrealistically low, the right questions should expose what has been omitted, deferred, or shifted onto the client—because price differences in construction are almost always about risk, not efficiency.
Missing scope is the #1 reason for unrealistically low bids. Low allowances also make bids look competitive but actually shift risk directly to the client. The absence of contingencies for potential problems that may arise is a good predictor of future drastic price adjustments and conflict between the contractor and client. A timeline of completion that looks too impressive can be a red flag for omitted labor hours, understaffing, and deferred work.
2. High-Pressure Sales Tactics
Every experienced businessman knows this: shady companies pressure prospective clients into making rushed decisions to circumvent due diligence.
Walk away when you hear: “If you don’t sign this week, we can’t guarantee availability.”
“Material prices are going up tomorrow.”
“We only have one slot left this season.”
“This is a one-time loyalty discount.”
“If you don’t do this now, your house could have really serious problems!” These lines are usually delivered with excessive friendliness and a ‘trust me’ demeanor.
Emotional rapport cannot be a substitute for transparency.
3. No Contract or a Poorly Written One
This one’s easy: no contract, no terms, no benchmarks, no specifications, no warranty, no legal remedies. A contract with loopholes to your disadvantage is just a draft that a bad contractor can leverage to escalate costs. Do your homework, consult with professionals and the more experienced, and carefully review the terms of the contract.
4. Lack of Local Presence or Proven Experience
Visit the contractor’s office. A good website is no assurance of a company’s legitimacy.
Though a firm may be properly registered, its lack of a local presence can have serious implications: complications in getting permits, slower response time, delayed site visits, absentee supervision of its subcontractors, weaker supplier networks, and warranty enforcement claims will be more expensive.
Validate claimed past projects if you can, especially if these are close to the location of your property. Communicate with past clients if you can and find out how their own experience with the company went.
5. They Can’t Explain Their Process
If, at the outset, a contractor is vague and just sketches a mental outline of his company’s processes to his prospective clients, they can be sure that mid-project, they will have even more of a problem finding out what’s going on. Even if the inability may not be malicious, this lack of clear communication will make even a dream house project very stressful. And at some point, the client might decide that they no longer want to deal with the contractor and hire another.
Statistics show that almost half of clients are willing to switch contractors after having a poor experience.
Why Working With an Established Local Team Matters
Choosing an established local construction team means partnering with professionals who are deeply connected to the community and invested in maintaining a long-term reputation. These teams understand the rhythms of local life, the challenges of the terrain, and the expectations of residents, which builds trust from the very start.
Fairbank Special Services has been part of the Kitsap County and Bainbridge Island community for decades, completing homes that reflect both quality craftsmanship and local sensibilities. Our team’s deep familiarity with county codes, site-specific challenges, and county logistics means homeowners can feel confident that every detail — from permits to final finishes — is handled with care and expertise. More than building custom houses, we build lasting relationships rooted in transparency, reliability, and community trust.
Comments